Question:
Alan John Stubbs has produced 5 books of poetry. These 3 poems are examples of his poetry, analyse the poems with close readings of each one and also compare them, with reference to whatever critical theory you think relevant.
When you have completed this analysis produce an essay with references.
Finally consider why the poetry of Alan John Stubbs has never been the subject of academic study.
a philosophical provocation
this tree is both an assertion and a dialogue
it is ambiguous and playfully sets out in branches
it is rooting too slowly to appreciate in inches
it is not just itself but also lichens and mosses
aggregate on its surfaces, and the spine of trunk
is a book of record in a way, and the flat leaf
a translator of light and air and water, a sheathe
of cares where a slaughter of aphids turn gunk
and tear into a million chews, or that tree frogs
may choose to hide beneath and snooze, or foxes
paw at when they parachute loose, and so this
is an interpretation, and that is all it is, a miss
heard call, a faint echo, an accumulation of
words sighing like leaves on a tree, or a stove
that is ready to cook the meal that's inside it.
This door is blind shut and we don't know it's lit.
this tree had flat shoes
'flatees' she would call them
broad not thin that tapered in
to the unbroken moss and liverwort covered earth
where crawling things make
something of themselves
apparently out of nothing
just like
she had all of that thicken and rise
foliage and flowers some-time
snatched from the air like a promise
as if thought could be solid drinking light
she would swallow streams making them
flow up her throat canals in defiance
of gravity itself
transported by affinity alone
until as easy on the ear exhalations of joy they became
cloud-form
laden with chemical speech saying
all of those things one life might say to another
she moves tenderly seeking a way between obstructions
joining strut limb to limb long toe to toe
knowing
something of the frisson of the little movements
inside her sleeve
outside her arms reach
she was always one for sensible shoes
small steps
gentle exercises
stretching out slowly as far as she could go and then coming
to rest
by the smallest of increments orienting
herself to the sun and easing through outside of notice
where green and sappy thought lives
as the movement of air through leaves
its vellum moss folds of consideration
lichen flecked caught in the act of vanishing
bats.
overwinter the plums, all ignored
shrank to bat like husks
sleeping fixed to the branches
in the scraped light
dried out
they clacked dryly against each other
the wind tugging their umbilicals
disappeared wreathed in white early flowers
were found hiding in the profusion when
trees were reborn
these corpses of sweet ones
overlooked late summer’s swells are
changed utterly now
with skins
all of white spores and pin-head orange
eggs waiting
they are become both beginning and end
birth and death
Alan John Stubbs: Nature, language, perception and the cycles of life
Introduction
The three poems supplied by Alan John Stubbs offer a particularly interesting starting point for critical examination because, although they share a preoccupation with the natural world, they approach it from markedly different intellectual and emotional perspectives. They are not simply nature poems in the conventional sense. Rather, they investigate the relationship between language and the material world, the processes by which living things develop and change, and the difficulty of distinguishing between the observer and the thing observed.
A striking feature of all three poems is their refusal to treat nature as passive scenery. Trees, leaves, plums, mosses, lichens and animals are not merely objects for human contemplation. They possess their own processes, histories and forms of agency. Human consciousness attempts to interpret these processes, but the poems repeatedly suggest that such interpretation is necessarily incomplete.
There is also a shared interest in transformation. In the first poem, a tree becomes a philosophical proposition, a text and an object of interpretation. In the second, the tree appears to possess a body, a consciousness and an almost human capacity for movement and thought. In the third, decaying fruit becomes the starting point for new life. The poems thus move from the epistemological question of how we know the world, through an imaginative exploration of identification with nature, to an acceptance of the interdependence of death and regeneration.
I shall approach the poems through several complementary critical perspectives:
· Ecocriticism: the relationship between literature, nature and the environment.
· Posthumanism: the questioning of human exceptionalism and the boundaries between human and non-human existence.
· Phenomenology: the relationship between perception, consciousness and the physical world.
· Deconstruction and poststructuralism: the instability of language and the impossibility of completely fixing meaning.
· Organic and process-based philosophies: the understanding of life as continuous transformation rather than a succession of discrete states.
These approaches are particularly appropriate because Stubbs's poetry seems interested less in describing nature than in questioning the assumptions through which human beings understand it.
One preliminary qualification is important: the analysis below is based on the three poems provided, not on a verified examination of all five poetry collections. Consequently, conclusions about Stubbs's entire poetic development or the reasons for his absence from academic criticism must remain provisional.
Part I: Close readings
1. 'a philosophical provocation'
The tree as proposition and philosophical problem
The title immediately establishes the poem's intellectual ambitions. The word 'provocation' suggests that the reader is being challenged rather than simply invited to admire a natural object. The indefinite article, 'a', is also significant. This is not necessarily the philosophical provocation, but one possible challenge among many.
The opening line makes the poem's intentions explicit:
this tree is both an assertion and a dialogue
The tree is simultaneously something that exists independently and something that becomes meaningful through interpretation. An 'assertion' implies a statement or claim, whereas a 'dialogue' implies an exchange between different positions. The juxtaposition raises a fundamental philosophical question: does the tree possess meaning in itself, or does meaning arise through the encounter between the tree and the consciousness observing it?
This is a question associated with phenomenology, particularly the work of Maurice Merleau-Ponty. In Phenomenology of Perception (1945), Merleau-Ponty challenges the division between a detached observing consciousness and an entirely separate external world. Perception is embodied and relational. We do not simply receive the world as information; we participate in its disclosure.
Stubbs's tree can be understood in these terms. It is neither simply an object nor merely an idea. It is an encounter.
The next line extends this ambiguity:
it is ambiguous and playfully sets out in branches
There is a pleasing double meaning here. The tree physically branches, but its branches also resemble the branching possibilities of thought. The natural object becomes a metaphor for intellectual complexity without ceasing to be a natural object.
The adverb 'playfully' prevents the philosophical investigation from becoming excessively solemn. There is humour in the suggestion that the tree itself might be conducting an experiment in ambiguity.
The inadequacy of measurement
The third line introduces a subtle criticism of human methods of understanding:
it is rooting too slowly to appreciate in inches
The word 'inches' invokes measurement, quantification and the desire to make growth intelligible through numerical units. Yet the tree's development operates on a timescale that resists immediate human appreciation.
There is an implied distinction between measurable growth and experienced growth. A tree can be measured, but measurement does not necessarily communicate what it means to grow.
This recalls Martin Heidegger's distinction between calculative and meditative thinking in 'The Question Concerning Technology' (1954). Calculative thinking seeks to organise the world into measurable and manageable units. Meditative thinking allows things to disclose themselves without immediately reducing them to practical or instrumental categories.
Stubbs does not reject measurement outright. Rather, he suggests that measurement is insufficient. The tree's reality exceeds the units through which we attempt to comprehend it.
Ecological interdependence
The fourth line is crucial:
it is not just itself but also lichens and mosses
The apparently individual tree is revealed as an ecological community. Its identity cannot be separated from the other organisms inhabiting its surfaces.
This is an important departure from an anthropocentric understanding of individuality. The tree is not an isolated object but a location of relationships.
The following lines develop this idea:
aggregate on its surfaces, and the spine of trunk is a book of record in a way
The metaphor of the trunk as a 'spine' introduces the human body, while 'book of record' introduces writing, memory and history. The tree becomes simultaneously organism, body and archive.
Its surface records time, but the record is not written in conventional language. Growth, weathering, colonisation by other organisms and physical change become forms of inscription.
The phrase 'in a way' is worth noticing. It qualifies the metaphor, preventing the tree from being entirely assimilated into a human system of meaning. It is a book, but only metaphorically.
This qualification becomes increasingly important as the poem progresses.
The leaf as translator
The next image is especially suggestive:
and the flat leaf a translator of light and air and water
The leaf performs a transformation between different forms of existence. It receives light, interacts with air and participates in the movement of water. Its biological activity makes it an intermediary between the tree and its environment.
Calling it a 'translator' anthropomorphises the leaf, but the metaphor also suggests that translation is not exclusively a human activity.
A leaf translates environmental conditions into biological processes. It converts light into chemical energy through photosynthesis.
The poem therefore uses a human cultural activity to describe a non-human biological process, while simultaneously suggesting that the biological process might be understood as a kind of language.
This is a characteristic posthumanist gesture: it unsettles the assumption that language, communication and meaningful activity belong exclusively to human beings.
The violence of the natural world
The poem then introduces a less harmonious aspect of nature:
a slaughter of aphids turn gunk and tear into a million chews
The language becomes deliberately abrasive. 'Slaughter' is an emotionally charged word, and 'gunk' is almost aggressively unpoetic.
This is important because Stubbs avoids presenting nature as an uncomplicated realm of beauty. The tree is a site of feeding, destruction, decay and survival.
The aphids are not simply decorative inhabitants. Their consumption and destruction are part of the ecological processes through which the tree exists.
The reference to tree frogs and foxes further complicates the tree's identity:
or that tree frogs may choose to hide beneath and snooze, or foxes paw at when they parachute loose
The tree becomes a shelter, a meeting point and an element in a much larger network of animal activity.
The slightly comic 'parachute loose' gives the foxes a surprising physical lightness. The poem moves freely between scientific observation, philosophical reflection and playful linguistic invention.
This tonal flexibility is one of its strengths.
The crisis of representation
The poem now turns explicitly towards its own status as a linguistic construction:
and so this is an interpretation, and that is all it is, a miss heard call, a faint echo
This is arguably the most important passage in the poem.
The speaker acknowledges that the poem is not the tree. It is an interpretation of the tree, and therefore inevitably partial.
The pun on 'miss' and 'heard' suggests both misunderstanding and mishearing. The poem is a response to something that cannot be fully captured.
There is a clear connection here with Jacques Derrida's understanding of language. In Of Grammatology (1967), Derrida challenges the assumption that words can provide transparent access to stable meanings. Meaning is produced through relationships between signs and is never entirely self-contained.
Stubbs's poem dramatises this problem. The tree exists, but the language used to describe it can only approach it indirectly.
The image of:
words sighing like leaves on a tree
brings the natural and linguistic worlds together once more. Words behave like leaves, while leaves themselves have already been presented as translators.
The metaphor is circular: language imitates nature, while nature becomes intelligible through language.
The following image:
or a stove that is ready to cook the meal that's inside it.
is more enigmatic. A stove contains the potential for transformation, but the meal is already inside it. The image suggests that interpretation is both preparatory and transformative: the poem contains possibilities that are not exhausted by what has yet been expressed.
The final two lines are particularly striking:
This door is blind shut and we don't know it's lit.
The abrupt shift from the tree to a door creates a sense of dislocation. The door suggests a threshold, a possible entrance into knowledge or understanding. Yet it is 'blind shut': inaccessible to ordinary perception.
The paradox that it is nevertheless 'lit' suggests that something exists beyond our ability to see it.
There may be knowledge or illumination available, but the means of access remain closed.
The poem therefore ends without resolving the philosophical problem with which it began. Its conclusion is deliberately resistant to closure.
Critical assessment
This is a self-conscious poem about the limits of representation. Its subject is ostensibly a tree, but its deeper subject is the relationship between reality, consciousness and language.
Its greatest achievement is the way it makes the philosophical problem concrete. Instead of presenting an abstract argument about the inadequacy of language, it makes the reader experience the difficulty of representing something as apparently simple as a tree.
Its occasional syntactical awkwardness and deliberately eccentric imagery may divide readers, but they also contribute to its sense of thought unfolding rather than arriving at a predetermined conclusion.
2. 'this tree had flat shoes'
The transformation of the tree into a living body
Where the first poem considers the philosophical implications of observing a tree, the second appears to enter into the tree's existence imaginatively.
The opening is immediately intriguing:
this tree had flat shoes 'flatees' she would call them
The colloquial 'flatees' introduces a human voice, perhaps remembered, perhaps imagined. The feminine pronoun 'she' creates an ambiguity that remains unresolved throughout the poem.
Who is 'she'? Is she the tree, a human observer, a child, a woman remembered by the speaker, or a composite of these possibilities?
This ambiguity is productive because the poem does not establish a firm distinction between human and vegetal identities.
The shoes suggest feet, but the tree's feet are its roots. The metaphor gives the tree a body that is simultaneously recognisable and fundamentally different from the human body.
There is also something charmingly domestic about the word 'flatees'. It creates an intimacy with the tree that contrasts with the more explicitly philosophical vocabulary of the first poem.
Roots, earth and the possibility of becoming
The next lines describe the shoes:
broad not thin that tapered in to the unbroken moss and liverwort covered earth
The image of footwear gradually merging into the earth suggests that the tree's identity cannot be separated from the ground in which it grows.
The roots are not simply an attachment to the soil. They constitute a relationship with an environment that is itself alive.
The phrase 'unbroken' is significant. It suggests continuity between organisms and their surroundings, rather than the separation implied by conventional human categories.
The following lines introduce a particularly important idea:
where crawling things make something of themselves apparently out of nothing
The phrase 'out of nothing' recalls the philosophical and biological mystery of emergence: the appearance of complex life and organisation from apparently undifferentiated materials.
The word 'apparently' is important. The speaker recognises that the impression of creation from nothing is misleading. What appears to be nothing is already a complex environment of processes and possibilities.
This is compatible with contemporary ecological thinking, particularly the emphasis on interdependence associated with thinkers such as Timothy Morton.
In The Ecological Thought (2010), Morton argues that ecological awareness requires us to abandon the idea that organisms exist as independent entities. Everything is implicated in everything else.
Stubbs's tree is similarly embedded in a network of relationships.
Vegetal consciousness and the human imagination
The poem then makes a remarkable imaginative leap:
she had all of that thicken and rise foliage and flowers some-time snatched from the air like a promise
The tree's growth is presented almost as an act of aspiration. Its foliage and flowers seem to be acquired from the air, as though the tree were reaching towards a future that has already been promised.
The phrase 'like a promise' gives the process an emotional dimension.
The next lines are even more ambitious:
as if thought could be solid drinking light
Here the poem appears to approach the idea of vegetal thought.
The tree's biological activity is represented as a form of cognition. Light becomes something that can be consumed, while thought becomes material.
This recalls the work of Michael Marder, particularly Plant-Thinking: A Philosophy of Vegetal Life (2013).
Marder challenges the assumption that plants are merely passive organisms without meaningful forms of existence. He explores the possibility of understanding vegetal life on its own terms rather than measuring it against human consciousness.
Stubbs's poem is not making a scientific claim that trees think in the human sense. Instead, it uses metaphor to question why thought should be imagined as exclusively human.
The tree's processes of growth, adaptation and response become possible equivalents of cognition.
Water, movement and the reversal of gravity
The following passage develops this imaginative identification:
she would swallow streams making them flow up her throat canals in defiance of gravity itself transported by affinity alone
The language gives the tree a digestive and circulatory system.
Water moves through the organism, but the description of its movement as 'swallowing' makes the process bodily and intimate.
The phrase 'defiance of gravity' is particularly interesting because it transforms the ordinary biological movement of water through a plant into an apparent act of resistance.
The tree is not simply acted upon by physical forces. It participates in processes that appear to challenge our ordinary understanding of movement.
'Affinity alone' introduces a scientific dimension. Water moves through plants through processes involving cohesion, adhesion and transpiration. The poem converts these processes into a language of attraction and relationship.
The word 'affinity' also carries emotional implications. It suggests attraction, sympathy and kinship.
Once again, Stubbs brings the scientific and the affective into contact.
Communication between forms of life
One of the poem's most interesting passages follows:
until as easy on the ear exhalations of joy they became cloud-form laden with chemical speech saying all of those things one life might say to another
This is a complex sequence of transformations.
Water becomes vapour, vapour becomes cloud, and the natural process is imagined as communication.
The phrase 'chemical speech' is particularly important. It implies that communication need not depend on conventional human language.
Plants communicate through chemical signals, including volatile organic compounds. Their environments are also characterised by exchanges involving fungi, microorganisms and other organisms.
The poem's language anticipates an ecological understanding of communication as something distributed throughout living systems.
The phrase 'all of those things one life might say to another' is tender, almost sentimental, but its sentiment is grounded in a material process.
The tree is communicating, not through words, but through its participation in the life of the world.
The ethics of restraint
The poem then introduces a more measured movement:
she moves tenderly seeking a way between obstructions
The verb 'moves' is significant. Trees are often perceived as stationary, but their growth involves continuous movement over time.
The poem invites the reader to perceive movement at a scale different from ordinary human experience.
The following phrase:
joining strut limb to limb long toe to toe
continues the bodily metaphor, but now the tree's structure resembles a system of articulated limbs.
The language suggests both physical extension and an attempt to establish contact.
The word 'tenderly' establishes an ethical dimension. The tree is not represented as an aggressive organism conquering its environment, but as something negotiating its way through it.
This is reinforced by:
knowing something of the frisson of the little movements inside her sleeve outside her arms reach
The distinction between what is within reach and what lies beyond it suggests the limits of perception.
The tree has its own scale of experience, one that cannot be fully translated into human terms.
The word 'frisson' gives the movement an almost erotic or emotional intensity. It implies that the smallest movements of life may possess an intensity that is invisible to an observer.
The aesthetics of slow growth
The next section is especially revealing:
she was always one for sensible shoes small steps gentle exercises stretching out slowly as far as she could go and then coming to rest
The poem returns to its opening image of footwear.
The shoes now become an emblem of a particular philosophy of existence: slow development, caution, moderation and persistence.
The tree grows through small increments rather than dramatic gestures.
There is an implied criticism of the human tendency to associate progress with speed and visible achievement.
The following lines extend this idea:
by the smallest of increments orienting herself to the sun and easing through outside of notice
The tree's existence is characterised by gradual adjustment. It responds to the sun and to its surroundings, but these changes may remain outside human awareness.
The phrase 'outside of notice' is particularly effective. It suggests that much of the world's activity takes place beyond the limits of human attention.
This is an important ecological insight: the world does not wait for us to observe it.
The disappearance of the individual
The final passage is perhaps the most beautiful and most ambiguous:
where green and sappy thought lives as the movement of air through leaves its vellum moss folds of consideration lichen flecked caught in the act of vanishing
The phrase 'green and sappy thought' combines the materiality of plant life with the abstract concept of thought.
The word 'sappy' is especially effective because it is simultaneously biological and colloquial. It refers to the substance of the tree, but also carries associations of emotional excess.
The image of air moving through leaves returns us to the relationship between organism and environment.
The tree is not a self-contained entity. It is continually animated by forces that pass through it.
'Vellum' introduces another reference to writing and recording. In the first poem, the trunk becomes a book; here, the moss becomes a material on which thought might be inscribed.
The final phrase, 'caught in the act of vanishing', is deliberately paradoxical.
The tree is simultaneously present and disappearing. Its individuality dissolves into the larger processes of which it is a part.
The poem therefore resists the notion that identity must be stable, bounded and permanent.
Critical assessment
This poem is more lyrical and imaginative than the first. Rather than explicitly questioning the possibility of representing nature, it attempts to imagine the world from within a vegetal perspective.
Its most interesting feature is its treatment of time. The tree moves, grows and responds, but at a pace that frequently escapes human attention.
The poem's anthropomorphism is potentially problematic: it uses human anatomy and human emotions to make vegetal life intelligible. However, it also undermines that very hierarchy by repeatedly suggesting that the tree possesses forms of activity and communication that do not depend on human recognition.
The result is an imaginative negotiation between identification and difference.
3. 'bats.'
The title and the initial act of transformation
The third poem is considerably shorter than the first two. Its brevity, however, gives it a concentrated intensity.
The title, 'bats.', is deliberately misleading. The poem is not primarily about bats as animals. It is about plums that have become bat-like through the processes of drying and decay.
The full stop in the title gives it an unusual finality. It seems to announce a subject, but the poem immediately unsettles the reader's expectations.
It opens:
overwinter the plums, all ignored shrank to bat like husks
The opening verb, 'overwinter', is particularly effective. It suggests a process of survival through an unfavourable season, but it is the plums, rather than living animals, that are undergoing this process.
The word also introduces a temporal dimension. The poem is concerned with what happens to things when they are left behind, when the season of their apparent usefulness has passed.
The phrase 'all ignored' is important. These are not carefully preserved fruits. They are neglected remnants, overlooked by human attention.
Their transformation takes place outside the sphere of human intention.
The simile 'bat like husks' gives the fruit a strange, almost Gothic appearance. The plums have become something resembling dead animals, suspended from branches.
The grotesque materiality of decay
The next lines develop the disturbing image:
sleeping fixed to the branches in the scraped light dried out
The word 'sleeping' personifies the fruit, but the adjective 'fixed' makes the image unsettling. Sleep normally suggests a temporary condition from which waking is possible. Here, the fruit appears trapped in a state between life and death.
'The scraped light' is an especially successful image. Light is not presented as warm or generous. It seems to have been rubbed away, leaving a harsh and depleted landscape.
The short line 'dried out' is almost clinical. Its simplicity contrasts with the preceding metaphorical language.
Stubbs is particularly effective when he allows a plain statement to follow an elaborate image.
The following lines introduce sound:
they clacked dryly against each other the wind tugging their umbilicals
The word 'clacked' is sharply auditory. It makes the fruit seem almost skeletal, as though their bodies have become hollow objects.
The 'umbilicals' are their stalks, but the metaphor is more than decorative. An umbilical cord connects a developing organism to its source of nourishment. Here, the connection remains physically visible after the fruit has lost its original vitality.
This produces an image of failed or suspended dependency.
The plums are still attached to the tree, but their relationship with it has changed.
The umbilical metaphor also anticipates the poem's eventual concern with the relationship between birth and death.
Disappearance and return
The next movement is abrupt:
disappeared wreathed in white early flowers were found hiding in the profusion when trees were reborn
The poem moves from winter into spring without providing a conventional description of the passing seasons.
The word 'disappeared' initially suggests that the plums have vanished. Yet they have not been destroyed. They have been obscured by the new flowering of the tree.
The phrase 'wreathed in white early flowers' is visually rich. The old fruit becomes surrounded by the signs of new life.
This creates an almost ritualistic image: the remnants of the previous season are decorated by the flowers of the next.
The word 'hiding' gives the plums an unexpected agency. They seem to be concealing themselves among the blossoms.
The phrase 'trees were reborn' is conventional enough in isolation, but its significance changes in this context. The tree's apparent rebirth does not eliminate what came before.
The old and the new occupy the same physical space.
This is a subtle but important ecological insight: natural renewal is not a complete replacement of the past. It is a process that incorporates what has already existed.
Death becomes a source of life
The central revelation arrives in the next passage:
these corpses of sweet ones overlooked late summer’s swells are changed utterly now
The word 'corpses' removes any remaining suggestion of innocent fruitfulness.
The plums are dead, or at least appear to be. The phrase 'sweet ones' preserves a memory of their former state, when they were ripe and desirable.
There is an implied criticism of human preference for the attractive and immediately useful. The plums were overlooked when they were past their best for consumption, but their apparent uselessness conceals another stage of ecological activity.
The phrase 'changed utterly' is particularly resonant.
It may recall W. B. Yeats's 'Easter 1916', in which the phrase describes a profound transformation of identity and historical circumstance.
Stubbs uses it in a different context: the transformation of neglected fruit into a new biological environment.
The possible allusion introduces an interesting tension. Yeats's transformation is political and historical; Stubbs's is ecological and biological.
In both cases, something apparently familiar becomes radically different.
The microscopic world
The final lines reveal the nature of this transformation:
with skins all of white spores and pin-head orange eggs waiting
The poem moves from the visible scale of fruit to the microscopic or near-microscopic world of fungi and other organisms.
The white spores suggest fungal colonisation, while the orange eggs suggest insect life or another biological presence.
The poem does not attempt to explain the exact species or biological processes involved. Its interest is in the spectacle of transformation.
The old fruit has become a habitat and a site of potential reproduction.
This is a significant departure from the human-centred understanding of waste. What has ceased to be useful to human beings may have become valuable to other organisms.
The ending is striking:
they are become both beginning and end birth and death
The grammatical construction 'they are become' has an archaic quality, lending the conclusion something of the authority of a philosophical pronouncement.
The two final lines compress the entire poem into a paradox.
The plums are dead, yet they contain the conditions of new life. They are endings that are simultaneously beginnings.
The poem refuses to separate these categories.
Ecocritical and philosophical interpretation
This poem can be read particularly productively through the concept of ecological succession.
In ecological systems, organisms and organic matter are continually incorporated into new relationships. Decay is not simply the termination of life. It is part of the processes through which nutrients, habitats and opportunities for new organisms become available.
The poem's central achievement is to make this process emotionally and imaginatively accessible.
It also recalls the work of Timothy Morton, particularly his challenge to the idea that nature is a harmonious, pristine entity existing separately from human activity.
Stubbs's natural world is neither picturesque nor reassuring. It includes corpses, spores, eggs, dried matter and the strange transformations of apparently useless things.
The poem also has affinities with the philosophy of impermanence found in Buddhist thought, although there is insufficient evidence to claim a direct Buddhist influence.
Its central proposition is that nothing can be understood in isolation from the processes that precede and follow it.
Critical assessment
Of the three poems, 'bats.' is perhaps the most formally economical.
Its short lines, abrupt transitions and concentrated imagery create a sense of inevitability. The poem does not explain its philosophical implications; it allows the reader to discover them through the transformation of the plums.
Its greatest strength is its refusal to sentimentalise nature. Decay is strange, sometimes grotesque, but it is also productive.
The final couplet is memorable because it does not offer a comforting resolution. Instead, it asks us to reconsider what we mean by an ending.
Part II: Comparative analysis
4. The three poems as a connected philosophical sequence
Read together, the poems suggest a coherent philosophical project.
Although their subjects and structures differ, they repeatedly examine three related questions:
1. What does it mean to perceive and understand the natural world?
2. Where does the identity of an organism begin and end?
3. How should we understand change, time and the relationship between life and death?
The poems can therefore be read as three complementary investigations into the nature of existence.
|
Poem |
Central concern |
Dominant movement |
|
'a philosophical provocation' |
The relationship between reality and representation |
From observation to uncertainty |
|
'this tree had flat shoes' |
The relationship between vegetal and human existence |
From identification to dissolution |
|
'bats.' |
The relationship between decay and regeneration |
From apparent death to new life |
The first poem is predominantly epistemological: it asks how we know.
The second is predominantly phenomenological and ontological: it asks what it means to exist and to experience.
The third is predominantly ecological and temporal: it asks how existence is transformed through time.
These are not rigid distinctions. All three poems contain elements of each concern.
5. Language, metaphor and the problem of representation
One of the most consistent features of Stubbs's poetry is its concern with language.
In the first poem, the tree becomes a book, the leaf a translator and the poem itself an imperfect echo.
In the second, the tree acquires shoes, a throat, arms, sleeves and something resembling thought.
In the third, the plums become corpses, their stalks become umbilicals and their decay becomes a form of reproduction.
In each case, metaphor creates a bridge between human experience and non-human existence.
However, there is an important difference.
In the first poem, metaphor is explicitly questioned. The speaker recognises that the tree is not actually a book or a dialogue, and that these descriptions are necessarily inadequate.
In the second, metaphor is used more freely. The poem does not continually interrupt its imaginative identification with the tree. It allows the metaphor to become an alternative way of perceiving vegetal existence.
In the third, metaphor becomes increasingly compressed. The plums are not merely like corpses: the poem invites us to see their transformation as a genuine passage between forms of life.
This progression is significant.
The first poem questions the reliability of language; the second explores its imaginative possibilities; the third demonstrates its ability to reveal relationships that ordinary perception overlooks.
There is also a consistent interest in the materiality of words themselves. 'Gunk', 'flatees', 'sappy', 'clacked', 'umbilicals' and 'spores' are not abstract or decorative terms. They have physical, sometimes uncomfortable qualities.
Stubbs's vocabulary is tactile and often deliberately resistant to conventional poetic prettiness.
6. Anthropomorphism and posthumanism
A central issue across all three poems is the relationship between human and non-human existence.
Traditionally, nature poetry has frequently presented the natural world through human emotional categories. Trees become symbols of endurance, flowers become symbols of beauty, and animals become symbols of freedom or innocence.
Stubbs uses some of these techniques, but he also complicates them.
The second poem is clearly anthropomorphic. The tree wears shoes, has a throat and possesses something resembling thought.
However, the effect is not simply to make the tree human.
Rather, the poem uses the human body as a means of imagining a different form of embodiment.
The tree's movement is slow, its circulation is botanical, and its communication is chemical.
The tree remains a tree.
This is where posthumanist theory becomes especially useful.
Rosi Braidotti, in The Posthuman (2013), challenges the traditional assumption that the human subject is the natural centre of philosophical and ethical consideration.
Similarly, Donna Haraway's Staying with the Trouble (2016) explores the complex relationships between human and non-human organisms, emphasising interdependence and shared existence.
Stubbs's poems repeatedly undermine the idea of the autonomous human observer.
In the first poem, the tree exists within a network of organisms and relationships.
In the second, the tree possesses forms of movement and communication that challenge human definitions of agency.
In the third, the apparently dead fruit becomes a habitat for other organisms.
Human beings are not the measure of these processes. They are observers who must learn to recognise forms of life and activity beyond their immediate experience.
Nevertheless, Stubbs does not completely escape anthropocentrism. His metaphors depend heavily on human bodies, human speech and human cultural objects.
This tension is productive. The poems are engaged in the difficult task of imagining the non-human without simply turning it into an extension of the human.
7. Time, duration and the limits of human perception
Time is another major connecting feature.
In 'a philosophical provocation', the tree roots too slowly for its growth to be appreciated in inches.
In 'this tree had flat shoes', growth occurs through 'small steps' and 'the smallest of increments'.
In 'bats.', the transformation of the plums requires the passage from late summer through winter into spring.
All three poems challenge the human preference for immediate results and easily observable change.
This recalls Henri Bergson's philosophy of durée, or lived duration.
In Time and Free Will (1889), Bergson distinguishes between lived time and the abstract, spatialised time measured by clocks and numbers.
For Bergson, time is not merely a series of separate units. It is a continuous process of becoming.
Stubbs's trees and plums inhabit this kind of duration.
The tree does not simply exist in a succession of measurable moments. Its life is an ongoing accumulation of growth, adaptation and interaction.
Similarly, the dead-looking plums are not simply objects belonging to the past. Their transformation connects one season to another.
This also has an important environmental implication.
Human beings frequently understand environmental change in relation to relatively short periods of personal or political time. Trees, ecosystems and geological processes operate on different scales.
The poems invite a reconsideration of human temporal assumptions.
8. The aesthetics of decay and the rejection of pastoral idealisation
The poems also have a distinctive relationship with the pastoral tradition.
Pastoral poetry has often represented nature as a refuge from human complexity: a place of beauty, harmony and renewal.
Stubbs's poetry is less reassuring.
The first poem includes the slaughter of aphids and the messy realities of ecological relationships.
The second contains a strange mixture of bodily imagery, chemical processes and gradual disappearance.
The third is explicitly concerned with dried fruit, corpses, spores and eggs.
Nature is not idealised.
This is particularly interesting in relation to what Lawrence Buell calls environmental imagination in The Environmental Imagination (1995).
Buell argues for an understanding of environmental literature that recognises the material environment as more than a background for human concerns.
Stubbs's poems meet this challenge because the natural world is not merely a setting. It is the active subject of the poetry.
The third poem is especially significant because it makes decay aesthetically productive without making it conventionally beautiful.
The plums are not restored to their former attractiveness. Their value lies in what they become.
This is an important distinction between a sentimental celebration of nature and a more radical ecological imagination.
9. Formal differences and poetic development
The three poems also reveal different approaches to poetic form.
'a philosophical provocation' is a relatively continuous sequence of thought. Its long lines, enjambment and shifting syntax reproduce the movement of an argument that repeatedly changes direction.
The absence of conventional punctuation allows images and propositions to flow into one another. The reader is encouraged to follow the movement of thought rather than wait for a neatly organised argument.
'this tree had flat shoes' is more fragmentary. Its short lines, isolated words and shifting indentation create a visual representation of gradual movement.
The poem seems to grow rather than simply proceed. Its form imitates its subject.
The isolated word 'knowing', for example, produces a pause that makes the subsequent description of the tree's movements feel like a new level of awareness.
'bats.' is more compressed and narrative. It moves through identifiable stages: winter, decay, spring, rediscovery and biological transformation.
Its brevity gives the ending considerable force.
The formal differences suggest that Stubbs is not committed to one fixed mode of writing. He adapts the structure of the poem to the nature of the subject.
This is a significant strength.
The first poem requires intellectual expansiveness; the second requires imaginative flexibility; the third requires compression.
Part III: Why has Alan John Stubbs received so little academic attention?
10. Establishing the publication context
Before considering the absence of academic criticism, it is important to establish that Stubbs is not simply an unpublished or entirely unknown poet.
There is evidence of a sustained publishing career.
Available bibliographical and publisher information identifies the following books:
· The Lost Box of Eyes (2016), published by The Onslaught Press.
· ident (2016), also published by The Onslaught Press.
· Tomorrow is the Tugboat of Today (2018).
· Sound About Hot (2020).
The publisher's description of The Lost Box of Eyes emphasises the combination of visually rich poems, human encounters and meditative nature poetry. It also includes a preface by Fiona Sampson, an established poet and critic.
![]()
AbeBooks+1
The description of ident characterises Stubbs's writing as playful, disturbing and provocative, with a particular interest in identity, childhood, travel and contemporary British society.
![]()
eBay UK+1
The Onslaught Press describes his later work as engaging with place, climate change, coronavirus, ordinary people, wildlife and environmental interdependence.
![]()
Nonfiction
These descriptions are significant because they suggest that the three poems considered here are not necessarily isolated experiments. They may be representative of a broader poetic interest in identity, environment, observation and transformation.
I would, however, distinguish between the existence of five published books, which is the premise of the question, and a fully verified bibliography. The available online catalogue records are inconsistent, and the complete titles and publication details of all five collections should be checked against the books themselves before a formal scholarly bibliography is submitted.
11. The economics and sociology of poetry publishing
One possible explanation for Stubbs's limited academic visibility is the structure of contemporary poetry publishing.
Matthew Sperling's chapter, 'Books and the Market: Trade Publishers, State Subsidies, and Small Presses', in The Oxford Handbook of Contemporary British and Irish Poetry (2013), provides a useful account of the changing relationship between poetry and the publishing industry.
Sperling describes the withdrawal of many commercial publishers from poetry and the subsequent growth of small independent presses.
This has created a situation in which a substantial amount of innovative poetry is published outside the mainstream commercial system.
![]()
OUP Academic
The Onslaught Press provides an example of this independent publishing environment.
Small presses can publish experimental, intellectually ambitious and formally unconventional poetry without requiring it to satisfy the commercial expectations of a large publishing house.
However, the consequences for visibility can be considerable.
The Poetry Society itself notes the limited financial resources devoted to poetry publishing and the difficulties faced by small presses in achieving widespread distribution.
![]()
The Poetry Society
The relationship between publication and academic recognition is therefore not straightforward.
A poet may publish several collections, develop a distinctive voice and establish a readership without necessarily entering the networks through which academic reputations are constructed.
Academic visibility depends partly on the availability of books, reviews, bibliographical records, archival material and opportunities for critical discussion.
It is possible that Stubbs's publishing history has not generated the institutional infrastructure necessary to sustain academic attention.
This is a plausible explanation, although it should not be mistaken for proof that his books have been deliberately excluded.
12. The problem of critical discoverability
Another issue is the relationship between literary criticism and discoverability.
The University of Liverpool's research project, The State of Poetry and Poetry Criticism in the UK and Ireland, examined nearly 20,000 poems and almost 3,000 critical articles published between 2012 and 2018.
Its findings demonstrated that poetry reviewing and criticism are concentrated within a relatively limited number of publications and networks.
![]()
University of Liverpool
The research was concerned particularly with inequalities of representation, but its broader significance is relevant here: the existence of a substantial body of poetry does not guarantee that it will receive sustained critical attention.
Poets who are regularly reviewed in influential journals have a greater chance of entering academic conversations.
Poets whose work circulates primarily through small presses, regional literary communities and relatively modest distribution networks may remain less visible.
This is particularly relevant to Stubbs, whose work appears to have a strong connection with the independent publishing and literary culture of Cumbria.
The available material also identifies his participation in the Carlisle Poetry Symposium.
![]()
andyhopkins
Such literary activity demonstrates that a poet can be part of an active literary community without necessarily receiving recognition from universities.
13. Is the poetry too difficult to categorise?
A further possible explanation concerns the character of the poetry itself.
Stubbs's work does not fit comfortably into a single critical category.
The three poems considered here might be described as:
· Ecological poetry.
· Philosophical poetry.
· Experimental lyric poetry.
· Posthumanist poetry.
· Nature poetry.
· Meditative poetry.
But none of these descriptions is entirely sufficient.
The first poem is concerned with epistemology and language.
The second is concerned with embodiment and vegetal consciousness.
The third explores ecological transformation and the relationship between life and death.
This intellectual range is potentially an advantage, but it can make a poet more difficult to position within established critical frameworks.
Academic criticism often develops around identifiable movements, historical periods, schools of writing or recognised literary relationships.
Stubbs's poems, at least in the examples supplied, appear to move freely between these categories.
They do not announce an obvious allegiance to a particular literary movement.
This does not make them less worthy of study. Indeed, their combination of philosophical inquiry and ecological imagination could provide the basis for a particularly interesting academic investigation.
However, it may make them less immediately identifiable to critics looking for a poet who can be placed within an existing literary narrative.
14. The absence of an established critical narrative
Academic reputations are often cumulative.
A poet is reviewed, discussed in literary journals, included in anthologies, taught in universities and subsequently becomes the subject of dissertations and scholarly articles.
These activities reinforce one another.
A poet who does not receive substantial early critical attention may find it difficult to enter this cycle.
This is not necessarily a judgement about literary quality.
Research into overlooked experimental poetry demonstrates that significant writing can remain outside established literary histories.
For example, scholarship on the Irish New Writers' Press has explored how small-press experimental poetry can disappear from conventional accounts of literary history.
![]()
MDPI
Similarly, Lise Jaillant's study 'Invisible Poetry: Women, Ethnic Minorities and the Forgotten History of Carcanet Magazine' (2021) demonstrates how important literary contributions can become obscured by the processes through which publishing histories and literary reputations are constructed.
![]()
DOI
These studies suggest that literary history is not simply a neutral record of the best writing. It is also a history of institutions, publishing decisions, critical networks and processes of cultural selection.
Stubbs's relative absence from academic discussion may therefore tell us something about the structures of literary recognition as well as about the reception of his poetry.
15. Does the poetry merit academic study?
In my view, the three poems provide a convincing basis for further scholarly investigation.
There are several possible research directions.
First, Stubbs and contemporary ecopoetics.
His representation of ecological interdependence, non-human agency and biological transformation could be examined in relation to contemporary environmental poetry.
Second, Stubbs and posthumanist thought.
The treatment of vegetal consciousness, embodied experience and the instability of the human/non-human distinction offers a promising subject for a study informed by Braidotti, Haraway and Marder.
Third, Stubbs and the philosophy of language.
The first poem is particularly suitable for an investigation of representation, metaphor and the limits of language.
Fourth, Stubbs and experimental lyric form.
The movement between conversational language, philosophical argument, unusual metaphor and compressed lyricism could be examined as a distinctive formal practice.
Fifth, Stubbs and the independent poetry press.
A study of his five collections could investigate the relationship between small-press publishing, regional literary culture and academic recognition.
The most interesting research project would probably combine these approaches rather than isolate one.
My provisional argument is that Stubbs deserves consideration as a contemporary poet whose work explores questions that have become increasingly important in literary and environmental criticism.
His lack of academic visibility should not be confused with an absence of intellectual substance.
Part IV: A critical essay
The following brings the close readings and theoretical discussion together into an essay suitable as the foundation for an academic article or postgraduate-level literary study.
The Tree, the Word and the Cycle of Life: An Ecocritical and Philosophical Reading of Three Poems by Alan John Stubbs
The Tree, the Word and the Cycle of Life: An Ecocritical and Philosophical Reading of Three Poems by Alan John Stubbs
Abstract
This essay examines three poems by contemporary British poet Alan John Stubbs: 'a philosophical provocation', 'this tree had flat shoes' and 'bats.'. It argues that the poems constitute a sustained exploration of the relationship between human consciousness, language and the natural world. Drawing on ec
Part IV: A critical essay
The following brings the close readings and theoretical discussion together into an essay suitable as the foundation for an academic article or postgraduate-level literary study.
The Tree, the Word and the Cycle of Life: An Ecocritical and Philosophical Reading of Three Poems by Alan John Stubbs
The Tree, the Word and the Cycle of Life: An Ecocritical and Philosophical Reading of Three Poems by Alan John Stubbs
Abstract
This essay examines three poems by contemporary British poet Alan John Stubbs: 'a philosophical provocation', 'this tree had flat shoes' and 'bats.'. It argues that the poems constitute a sustained exploration of the relationship between human consciousness, language and the natural world. Drawing on ecocriticism, phenomenology, posthumanism and poststructuralist theories of representation, the essay investigates how Stubbs challenges conventional distinctions between human and non-human existence. The poems are considered as complementary investigations into perception, vegetal agency and ecological transformation. Particular attention is given to their use of metaphor, unconventional syntax, material imagery and temporal structures. The essay concludes by considering why Stubbs, despite having published five poetry collections, appears to have received little academic attention. It suggests that the marginal position of independent poetry publishing, the limited infrastructure of poetry criticism and the difficulty of positioning his work within established literary categories may help explain this neglect. It proposes that Stubbs's poetry merits further scholarly consideration, particularly within contemporary ecopoetics and posthumanist literary studies.
Introduction
Alan John Stubbs is a contemporary poet whose work, at least in the three poems considered here, demonstrates an unusual combination of philosophical speculation, ecological awareness and linguistic experimentation. His poetry is concerned with the natural world, but it would be misleading to classify it simply as nature poetry. Rather than presenting nature as a picturesque setting for human emotions, Stubbs investigates the processes through which the natural world exists independently of human observation, while simultaneously questioning the limitations of the language through which humans attempt to understand it.
The three poems considered in this essay provide particularly revealing examples of these concerns. 'a philosophical provocation' examines the tree as both a physical organism and an object of interpretation. 'this tree had flat shoes' develops an imaginative identification with vegetal existence, exploring the possibility of understanding plants through forms of embodied and non-human experience. 'bats.' considers the transformation of neglected fruit through decay, presenting death and regeneration as interconnected aspects of ecological existence.
Although different in form and tone, the poems share an interest in the instability of apparently fixed categories: subject and object, human and non-human, life and death, language and reality. Their philosophical implications can be explored through several critical traditions, particularly ecocriticism, phenomenology, posthumanism and poststructuralism.
The central argument of this essay is that Stubbs's poetry attempts to move beyond an anthropocentric understanding of nature. It presents the natural world as a complex network of processes and relationships, within which human consciousness is only one possible form of engagement.
Language and the problem of representation
In 'a philosophical provocation', Stubbs immediately establishes the relationship between natural existence and human interpretation:
'this tree is both an assertion and a dialogue'
The distinction between assertion and dialogue is fundamental. An assertion suggests an independent statement of existence, whereas dialogue implies an exchange between different perspectives. The tree exists independently, but its significance emerges through an encounter with the observer.
The poem therefore introduces an epistemological problem: whether the natural world can ever be understood independently of the language and conceptual frameworks through which it is perceived.
The tree is described as something that 'playfully sets out in branches'. The physical branching of the tree becomes a metaphor for the branching possibilities of thought. The natural object and the intellectual process are brought together, suggesting that perception is not a passive act but an imaginative engagement.
This concern recalls Maurice Merleau-Ponty's Phenomenology of Perception (1945). Merleau-Ponty rejects a rigid separation between the perceiving subject and the external world, arguing that perception is fundamentally embodied. The world is encountered through our participation in it rather than through detached observation.
Stubbs's tree can be understood in similar terms. It is neither simply an object awaiting description nor merely a product of the speaker's imagination. It is something encountered through an ongoing relationship between physical existence and human consciousness.
The poem becomes increasingly concerned with the inadequacy of representation. The trunk is described as 'a book of record in a way', while the leaf becomes 'a translator of light and air and water'. These metaphors suggest that nature possesses its own systems of inscription and transformation.
The leaf is particularly significant. Its biological function is represented through the human activity of translation, suggesting that communication and transformation are not exclusively linguistic or human activities.
The poem subsequently acknowledges the limitations of its own language:
'and so this
is an interpretation, and that is all it is, a miss
heard call, a faint echo'
The speaker recognises that the poem cannot reproduce the tree itself. It can only offer an interpretation, an imperfect response to something that remains partly inaccessible.
This is compatible with Jacques Derrida's critique of stable meaning in Of Grammatology (1967). Derrida demonstrates that language does not provide transparent access to an independent and completely fixed meaning. Meaning emerges through relationships between signs and remains open to further interpretation.
Stubbs dramatises this difficulty through the relationship between the tree and the poem. The natural object is present, but the language describing it can only approximate its existence.
The final image, 'This door is blind shut and we don't know it's lit', intensifies the problem. The door suggests a possible entrance into knowledge, but it remains inaccessible. Its illumination exists beyond the limits of perception.
The poem consequently ends without resolving its central philosophical problem. Its uncertainty is not a weakness but an essential part of its argument.
Vegetal existence and posthumanist imagination
Where the first poem questions the possibility of representing nature, 'this tree had flat shoes' attempts to imagine vegetal existence from within.
The opening image is immediately unconventional:
'this tree had flat shoes
"flatees" she would call them'
The tree is given a body, and its roots become footwear. The colloquial 'flatees' introduces an intimate human voice, while the feminine pronoun creates uncertainty about the identity of the figure being described.
The poem proceeds by combining human anatomy with botanical processes. The tree appears to possess a throat, arms and limbs. Its circulation of water becomes an act of swallowing, while its growth becomes a form of movement.
The most intellectually ambitious moment occurs in the lines:
'as if thought could be solid drinking light'
Here Stubbs approaches the possibility of vegetal consciousness. Light becomes something consumed, while thought acquires a material dimension.
This imaginative strategy can be considered in relation to Michael Marder's Plant-Thinking: A Philosophy of Vegetal Life (2013). Marder challenges the philosophical tendency to regard plants as passive objects, proposing that vegetal existence deserves consideration on its own terms.
Stubbs's poem does not claim that plants possess human consciousness. Instead, it questions the assumption that human consciousness should be the standard against which all other forms of life are measured.
The description of water moving through the tree's 'throat canals in defiance / of gravity itself' develops this challenge. Botanical processes are represented through bodily experience, but they also retain their distinctiveness.
The movement of water becomes an expression of 'affinity alone', suggesting that biological activity is characterised by relationships and attractions rather than by isolated individual action.
The phrase 'chemical speech' is equally revealing. The tree's biological exchanges become a form of communication, culminating in the suggestion that these processes express 'all of those things one life might say to another'.
The poem thus challenges the assumption that meaningful communication must depend upon human language.
Its wider philosophical implications are posthumanist. Rosi Braidotti, in The Posthuman (2013), questions the centrality traditionally assigned to the human subject. Donna Haraway's Staying with the Trouble (2016) similarly explores the interdependence of human and non-human organisms.
Stubbs's tree exists through relationships with its environment, responding to light, water and physical obstructions. Its identity is not independent of these relationships.
The final image, 'lichen flecked caught in the act of vanishing', suggests that individual identity is ultimately unstable. The tree is simultaneously present and disappearing into the wider ecological processes that sustain it.
There remains a tension in the poem between anthropomorphism and the recognition of non-human difference. Stubbs relies on human anatomy and emotional vocabulary to make vegetal existence intelligible. Nevertheless, the result is not simply a humanised tree. It is an imaginative attempt to expand the reader's understanding of what constitutes living experience.
Decay, regeneration and ecological time
The third poem, 'bats.', approaches the natural world through the transformation of apparently dead matter.
Its opening describes neglected plums that have 'shrank to bat like husks'. The fruit is presented as something suspended between organic life and death.
The word 'overwinter' establishes the poem's temporal structure. The plums survive through the winter, although their original form and usefulness have disappeared.
Their condition is described through images of physical deterioration:
'they clacked dryly against each other
the wind tugging their umbilicals'
The metaphor of the umbilical cord is especially significant. The plums remain attached to the tree, although their relationship with it has changed. The connection suggests both dependency and the persistence of an earlier form of life.
The poem then moves into spring:
'disappeared wreathed in white early flowers
were found hiding in the profusion when
trees were reborn'
The apparent disappearance of the fruit is followed by its rediscovery among the flowers. The new growth of the tree does not eliminate the remnants of the previous season. The old and new occupy the same ecological space.
The transformation becomes explicit in the description of the plums as 'corpses of sweet ones'. Their former attractiveness has been replaced by decay.
Yet this decay is not presented as meaningless destruction. The skins are covered with 'white spores and pin-head orange / eggs waiting'. The fruit has become a habitat and a site of further biological activity.
This is consistent with an ecological understanding of decomposition, in which dead organic matter participates in processes that sustain other organisms.
Timothy Morton, in The Ecological Thought (2010), challenges the conventional tendency to imagine nature as a harmonious and separate realm. Ecological existence involves complex interrelationships that cannot be reduced to picturesque ideas of natural beauty.
Stubbs's poem offers a similar perspective. Its natural world contains dried fruit, corpses, fungi and eggs. Decay is neither hidden nor sentimentalised.
The final lines provide the philosophical conclusion:
'they are become both beginning and end
birth and death'
The poem refuses to distinguish between life and death as entirely separate conditions. The dead fruit has become the foundation for other forms of existence.
The phrase 'changed utterly' may recall W. B. Yeats's 'Easter 1916'. However, whereas Yeats uses transformation in a political and historical context, Stubbs employs it to describe ecological change.
The comparison is suggestive rather than proof of deliberate allusion.
The poem's compressed form is particularly effective. Its short lines and abrupt transitions reproduce the movement from one season to another without unnecessary explanation. Its final couplet transforms a small observation into a general proposition about existence.
Time and the limits of human perception
An important connection between all three poems is their treatment of time.
In 'a philosophical provocation', the tree grows too slowly to be appreciated in inches. In 'this tree had flat shoes', development occurs through 'small steps' and 'the smallest of increments'. In 'bats.', the transformation of the plums requires the passage of several seasons.
The poems challenge the human preference for immediate and measurable change.
Henri Bergson's concept of durée, developed in Time and Free Will (1889), offers a useful theoretical framework. Bergson distinguishes lived duration from abstract, spatialised time. Time is not simply a succession of separate units but a continuous process of becoming.
Stubbs's natural subjects inhabit this continuous duration. Their existence cannot be adequately understood through the short periods of attention ordinarily available to human observers.
This is particularly important in ecological writing, where environmental processes often operate on timescales that exceed individual human experience.
The poems encourage a more patient form of attention, one capable of recognising gradual change and processes that remain largely invisible.
Ecocriticism and the rejection of the conventional pastoral
The three poems also challenge conventional pastoral representations of nature.
Traditional pastoral poetry has often presented nature as a place of beauty, harmony and refuge from human society. Stubbs's poetry offers a more complicated environment.
The first poem includes predation and the destruction of aphids. The second explores the bodily and chemical processes of vegetal existence. The third concentrates on decay and decomposition.
Nature is not presented as a perfect or harmonious system.
Lawrence Buell's The Environmental Imagination (1995) provides a useful framework for considering this distinction. Buell emphasises the importance of recognising the physical environment as an active presence rather than simply a background for human concerns.
Stubbs's poems fulfil this principle particularly well. The natural world is not merely a metaphor for human experience. It has its own processes, relationships and temporal structures.
His poetry therefore moves towards an ecological understanding of existence in which the human observer is one participant within a larger network of life.
Formal experimentation and poetic method
The poems also demonstrate a significant degree of formal variety.
'a philosophical provocation' is characterised by extended lines, enjambment and shifting syntactical structures. Its form reflects the movement of philosophical thought, continually developing and revising its own propositions.
'this tree had flat shoes' employs shorter lines, irregular spacing and fragmentary syntax. Its structure creates an impression of gradual development, reflecting the slow growth of its central subject.
'bats.' is more compressed and sequential. Its progression through winter, spring and biological transformation gives it a concentrated narrative movement.
These differences suggest that Stubbs adapts poetic form to the requirements of his subject.
His vocabulary is also distinctive. Words such as 'gunk', 'flatees', 'sappy', 'clacked' and 'umbilicals' combine colloquial expression with scientific and philosophical language.
The result is a poetry that does not consistently privilege conventional lyric beauty. It is prepared to introduce awkwardness, humour and material discomfort.
This linguistic experimentation is particularly important because it challenges the idea that nature poetry must depend on an established vocabulary of beauty and transcendence.
Why has Alan John Stubbs received so little academic attention?
The apparent absence of sustained academic criticism of Stubbs's poetry raises an interesting question about the relationship between literary value and literary recognition.
Stubbs has published several poetry collections, including The Lost Box of Eyes (2016), ident (2016), Tomorrow is the Tugboat of Today (2018) and Sound About Hot (2020). The bibliographical record also identifies a fifth collection, although its title and publication details require confirmation against a reliable publisher's catalogue.
The available descriptions suggest a poet whose interests extend beyond the natural world to identity, childhood, travel, social observation and environmental change.
His limited academic visibility may be partly explained by the structure of contemporary poetry publishing.
Matthew Sperling's chapter 'Books and the Market: Trade Publishers, State Subsidies, and Small Presses' in The Oxford Handbook of Contemporary British and Irish Poetry (2013) documents the withdrawal of many commercial publishers from poetry and the consequent importance of independent presses.
Small presses provide opportunities for experimental and specialist poetry, but they frequently operate with limited resources for distribution, publicity and promotion.
This can restrict the circulation of books beyond their immediate literary communities.
The Poetry Society has similarly drawn attention to the limited financial resources available for poetry publishing and the difficulties faced by small presses.
A second factor is the structure of literary criticism itself. The University of Liverpool's research project on poetry and poetry criticism in the UK and Ireland demonstrated the concentration of reviewing and critical discussion within a relatively limited number of literary publications.
Poets who receive sustained attention from influential journals and critics are more likely to enter academic discussions.
Those whose books circulate primarily through independent publishing networks may be less visible, irrespective of their literary abilities.
A third possibility concerns the difficulty of categorising Stubbs's work. His poetry combines philosophical speculation, experimental lyricism, ecological observation and posthumanist implications. It does not fit neatly into a single established literary movement.
This may make it less immediately attractive to critics working within narrowly defined literary categories.
However, these explanations remain hypotheses. Establishing why Stubbs has not received sustained academic attention would require a more systematic examination of academic databases, poetry journals, publisher archives, library catalogues and reviews.
It would be inappropriate to conclude that his work has been deliberately excluded or that its absence from academic criticism necessarily reflects a failure of literary quality.
Indeed, the three poems examined here suggest several promising avenues for further research.
His representation of vegetal existence could be examined alongside contemporary posthumanist philosophy. His treatment of decay and regeneration offers opportunities for research into ecopoetics. His concern with the instability of language provides a basis for engagement with phenomenology and poststructuralism.
A study of all five collections could also establish whether these interests represent a consistent development in his poetic practice.
Conclusion
The three poems by Alan John Stubbs demonstrate a sustained interest in the relationship between human consciousness and the natural world.
'a philosophical provocation' investigates the limits of representation, suggesting that the natural world always exceeds the language through which humans attempt to understand it.
'this tree had flat shoes' explores the possibility of imagining vegetal existence beyond conventional anthropocentric assumptions, presenting the tree as a living and responsive participant in ecological processes.
'bats.' examines the relationship between decay and regeneration, revealing how apparently dead matter becomes the foundation for new life.
Together, the poems challenge the separation of human and non-human existence, the assumption that nature is a passive object of observation, and the tendency to understand life and death as opposing conditions.
Their philosophical significance lies partly in their willingness to leave questions unresolved. They do not offer a comprehensive theory of nature. Instead, they encourage a more attentive and imaginative relationship with the world.
Stubbs's relative absence from academic literary criticism is therefore worthy of investigation in its own right. His work appears to offer productive opportunities for contemporary ecocritical, phenomenological and posthumanist scholarship.
The most important conclusion is that literary recognition and literary significance are not identical. The absence of a substantial critical literature should not be taken as evidence that a poet has little to contribute.
On the evidence of these three poems, Alan John Stubbs merits more sustained critical attention than he appears to have received.
His poetry asks us to reconsider what a tree is, what it might mean to think beyond the human, and whether death can ever be understood as an absolute ending. These are substantial philosophical and ecological questions, and Stubbs approaches them with an imaginative freedom that deserves further scholarly investigation.
References
Primary texts
Stubbs, Alan John (2016a). The Lost Box of Eyes. The Onslaught Press.
Stubbs, Alan John (2016b). ident. The Onslaught Press.
Stubbs, Alan John (2018). Tomorrow is the Tugboat of Today. The Onslaught Press.
Stubbs, Alan John (2020). Sound About Hot. The Onslaught Press.
Stubbs, Alan John. 'a philosophical provocation', 'this tree had flat shoes' and 'bats.'. Poems supplied for this study. Collection and publication details not established.
Critical and theoretical works
Bergson, Henri (1889). Time and Free Will: An Essay on the Immediate Data of Consciousness. Translated by F. L. Pogson. London: George Allen & Unwin.
Braidotti, Rosi (2013). The Posthuman. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Buell, Lawrence (1995). The Environmental Imagination: Thoreau, Nature Writing, and the Formation of American Culture. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Derrida, Jacques (1967). Of Grammatology. Translated by Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Haraway, Donna J. (2016). Staying with the Trouble: Making Kin in the Chthulucene. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Heidegger, Martin (1954). 'The Question Concerning Technology'. In The Question Concerning Technology and Other Essays. Translated by William Lovitt. New York: Harper & Row, 1977.
Marder, Michael (2013). Plant-Thinking: A Philosophy of Vegetal Life. New York: Columbia University Press.
Merleau-Ponty, Maurice (1945). Phenomenology of Perception. Translated by Donald A. Landes. London: Routledge, 2012.
Morton, Timothy (2010). The Ecological Thought. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Research on poetry publishing and literary recognition
Jaillant, Lise (2021). 'Invisible Poetry: Women, Ethnic Minorities and the Forgotten History of Carcanet Magazine'. The Review of English Studies, 72(306), pp. 756–774.
Sperling, Matthew (2013). 'Books and the Market: Trade Publishers, State Subsidies, and Small Presses'. In Peter Robinson (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Contemporary British and Irish Poetry. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 191–212.
University of Liverpool, Centre for New and International Writing (2018). The State of Poetry and Poetry Criticism in the UK and Ireland: January 2012–March 2018.
The Poetry Society. 'Frequently Asked Questions: Publishing Poetry'. The Poetry Society website.
Publisher and bibliographical sources
The Onslaught Press. Catalogue and biographical descriptions of Alan John Stubbs's collections.
Evertype Publications. Nonfiction and Poetry Publishing Catalogue. Bibliographical entry for Alan John Stubbs and his collections.
Part V: My overall assessment and recommendations
There is an important distinction I would make between the literary quality of the three poems and their potential significance as a body of work.
I think their most interesting characteristic is that they are not simply poems about nature. They are poems about the difficulty of understanding existence when human beings are no longer assumed to be its central organising principle.
Three particularly important observations emerge.
1. Stubbs is interested in the limits of human knowledge.
The first poem is almost a philosophical essay disguised as a nature poem. It recognises that the tree is always more than the language used to describe it.
2. He experiments with the possibility of non-human consciousness.
The second poem is especially interesting in relation to contemporary plant philosophy. Its imaginative identification with a tree raises questions about what constitutes agency, communication and thought.
3. He understands nature as a process rather than a collection of objects.
The third poem is perhaps the most successful in its economy. It demonstrates that death and decay are not simply endings but stages in the continuing activity of the natural world.
An important bibliographical point
I would want to establish the complete publication history before presenting the essay as a finished academic article. The publicly accessible records I located do not consistently identify all five collections. The titles The Lost Box of Eyes, ident, Tomorrow is the Tugboat of Today and Sound About Hot are identifiable, but the fifth title needs verification. Some catalogue records also contain later collected-poems editions, which should not automatically be counted as separate collections.
There is also a more important research question: whether the three supplied poems have appeared in one of the five collections, and whether their original publication dates can be established.
The most promising academic direction
Recommended research direction
I would suggest developing the work into a study entitled:
'Beyond the Human Observer: Ecological Consciousness, Language and Non-Human Agency in the Poetry of Alan John Stubbs'.
This would be more original and academically persuasive than a general study of his nature poetry.
It would position Stubbs in relation to:
· Michael Marder's philosophy of plant life.
· Timothy Morton's ecological thought.
· Donna Haraway's posthumanist approach to interdependence.
· Maurice Merleau-Ponty's phenomenology.
· Contemporary ecopoetics.
It would also provide an argument for why Stubbs merits academic attention rather than simply asserting that he has been overlooked.
One final qualification: I would not yet claim that Stubbs has never been academically studied. What the preliminary research supports is that I have not identified an established body of academic scholarship devoted to him. Demonstrating an absolute absence would require a systematic bibliographical search.
The strongest contribution might actually be to make the first substantial critical study of his poetry, establishing both its literary characteristics and its place within contemporary British ecopoetics.
No comments:
Post a Comment
All Comments are Welcome.